How scoring works

The short version

🏈 Official GM accounts

Every real NFL GM gets one OFFICIAL account (league “Historical Official”), named like “Brad Holmes - Detroit Lions GM”. If we can't confirm who ran a team's draft, the account just says “Official”.

Each account holds that GM's real draft for every year he ran it, with no trades and his real picks at their real slots. On the leaderboard you can look at a single draft year or at all years combined.

Real drafts don't get “accuracy” points, since they are the results. They're scored only on player performance.

📈 Player performance (value over expected)

The big question: did this pick play better or worse than a typical player taken at that spot?

1. Rate each season

Every season, each player gets a 0–100 percentile at his position, ranked against all NFL players at that position who saw the field that year, not just rookies. It uses the stats that matter for the position:

2. Average the seasons

A player's seasons are averaged, with later seasons counting a bit more so growth shows up. The current season counts in proportion to how much of it has been played. A season with no snaps counts as 0, so busts and lost years hurt.

3. Compare with his draft slot

Early picks are expected to be better. The expected percentile is about 79 at pick #1, 67 at #32, 45 at #100 and 17 at #250. That curve comes from the real 2022–2025 drafts. Each class is also measured against its own average, so a young class isn't punished just for being young.

Example: pick #32 (expected ≈ 67) whose seasons average 80 is about 10 percentile points ahead, which is worth +1 point. Every 10 percentile points is 1 point.

4. Caps

Each pick scores between -3 and +5, and one draft's total stays between -20 and +30. That way one superstar or one bust can't decide everything. The 2026 class is marked PROVISIONAL while its rookies play their first season.

Your official draft

Your own drafts get performance points too, but only your official draft counts: one completed draft with trades turned off, per draft year. The first one you finish becomes official automatically. You can switch it on any eligible draft's results page (“Make this my official draft”).

🎯 Mock-draft accuracy

Once real results are in, each pick you made (CPU picks don't count) earns:

Your draft score is the total, also shown as a % of the max (10 per pick). Only rounds with complete real results are scored. If a pick was traded, “team” means whoever used it.

🧢 GM career season score

Each draft year in a career is a season. Once real results exist, the season adds up:

Before results exist, a season shows a provisional score (value, trades, development and performance) that doesn't count yet. Your career total is the sum of your graded seasons.

🏅 Grades, badges, streaks & levels

These are just for fun and don't change any score.

Draft grade

Every draft's letter grade comes from player performance (the value-over-expected points), not from mock accuracy. It works the same for official GM drafts and your own drafts. Your non-official drafts get a grade too, but only your official draft counts toward your GM score.

A+ 12+ · A 9+ · A- 6+ · B+ 4+ · B 2+ · B- 0.5+ · C+ -1+ · C -2.5+ · C- -4+ · D -7+ · F below -7.

The cut-offs were chosen so the real NFL drafts of 2022–2025 spread from A+ to F (a typical real draft scores around 0, which is a C+). Until the players have NFL data, or while the class is still in its rookie season, the grade shows Pending. Mock accuracy is still shown on each draft as an info stat.

Badges

Streaks

Draft streak: how many of your most recent graded mocks in a row hit 40%+ mock accuracy. Hot streak: your longest run of picks worth 6+ points each in one draft.

GM level & rating

You earn XP from your positive season scores, plus 10 for every completed season and 5 for every badge. Levels: Intern (0), Area Scout (60), National Scout (150), Director of Scouting (300), Assistant GM (500), General Manager (800), Executive of the Year (1200). Your GM rating (40–99) is based on your average season score.

Top & bottom 5 picks

Tap a name on the leaderboard to see that GM's 5 best and 5 worst picks. When official-draft performance data exists, they're ranked by value over expected. Otherwise they're ranked by mock points.

Leaderboard tie-breaks

GM board: total, then average season, best season, exact hits, then badges. Mock board: best score, then exact hits, then average %.

🔁 Trades & the pick-value chart

Trades use the Rich Hill draft value chart (#1 = 1000; source, Pats Pulpit). You can trade current picks and picks up to 2 years out with one CPU team at a time. A future 1st is valued like a mid-round pick one round later: next year's 1st is about #48.

A CPU team says yes when it gets at least 5% more value than it gives. It wants about 10% more when it's trading up, about 5% more when its top need is on the board, and a small fixed “mood” of ±3% applies, so the same offer always gets the same answer.

#1 1000#2 717#3 514#5 468#10 369#16 305#24 237#32 184#33 180#48 121#64 80#96 39#128 19#160 10#224 3

Stats: Pro-Football-Reference.com via nflverse